Okay I should have been really questioning this since this is something that is generally important for me to know, but everyone was a little testy and since typing is a good way for me to be really inhibited I'll post some of my nitpicky "issiu here.
EXT. GARDEN-Sunrise
A small two story building with a garage-like tool shed as its first floor is situated in the corner of a plot of land surrounded by dry brush and small trees. At the center of the plot stands a large withered tree. Its leaves are few, and dull in color, but the trunk is strong. A GARDENER stands at the center of the garden, surveying his surroundings. He picks up and inspects an acorn from the dirt beneath the central tree. It is old, brittle, just a husk. He turns to the tool shed. There is a large crate in the threshold of the tool shed.
Okay... How is this shot composed? Do we start the short literally with the gardener standing in the middle of the garden?
A ROBOT stands, activated. The crate, with the word “CARETAKER” printed on it lies open, next to ROBOT. ROBOT takes in its surroundings. The GARDENER watches it, with expectation.
Do we see the gardener walk to the toolshed? Apparently he turned to the tool shed and sees the robot. So what does "Watches it with expectation" mean? This is very oblique!
ROBOT turns and stares blankly at the GARDENER. The GARDENER smiles, and gives ROBOT a small push toward the garden.
If we're in the exterior of the toolshed does that mean that he pushes him towards the direction of the garden. The way this is written it implies we're in the threshold of the toolshed but outside at the same time. This needs to be clear!
The GARDENER and ROBOT are in the center of the garden. ROBOT holds a sapling, and the GARDENER digs a hole. Turning to ROBOT, he wipes the sweat off his forehead and smiles. The GARDENER grasps the sapling from ROBOT’s arms.
There is neither a transition nor a segway from this last scene? Was there a fade? Is this a cut? Do we jump right into the digging of the hole? Is there an establishing shot since this is a completely different scene?
ROBOT watches the GARDENER work, studying his moves intently.
The GARDENER places the tree in the hole and pats it down with soil.
The GARDENER turns back and smiles at ROBOT.
ROBOT looks at the gardener and then looks at the sapling. ROBOT nods, appearing to understand the task laid out by the GARDENER.
The GARDENER hands him the shovel. The GARDENER watches ROBOT, while holding a second sapling.
ROBOT takes a few steps and attempts to dig, but it’s shovel is abruptly held back by the GARDENER.
Had the GARDENER not stopped ROBOT’s action, a previously planted sapling that would have been struck by the shovel.
While holding the sapling with one arm, the GARDENER guides the position of the shovel, to avoid the nearby plants.
The GARDENER lets go, and ROBOT starts digging.
The GARDENER sighs and shakes his head slightly, with a look of relief on his face.
This way the actions are described are fine. But there isn't a "ending" to this scene? The scene ends with the gardener relieved. Am I supposed to cut after this? Do I fade out? If I do fade out of this there's a strange disconnect, because I'm doing this after an action.
The GARDENER and ROBOT are tending to the shrubs towards the side of the tool shed.
The GARDENER shows the subtlety and nuance of pruning the sapling. He gently pulls a branch and clips a few dry leaves off.
ROBOT intently watches the GARDENER, its motions indicating enthusiasm.
The GARDENER turns to ROBOT and hands him the pruning shears. He nods slowly.
ROBOT gets up close to the sapling. ROBOT replicates the actions of the gardener. Overconfident, gets carried away in its activity.
Leaves and branches fall. As the last leaf falls to the ground the ROBOT steps back and sees a bare mutilated sapling.
ROBOT drops its head in shame. The GARDENER shows no displeasure at the actions, and pats the robot on the back. He motions for ROBOT to follow.
Same issues with the last scene. How did we get here? How do I transition into this?
The pair moves into the tool shed. Different tools line the walls, and saplings in buckets sit on a long table against the wall.
The pair walks towards the table. ROBOT’s actions betray its feelings about the event that transpired. It slouches and shuffles its feet. The GARDENER picks up a sapling and begins to head back. ROBOT follows suit, but stops, seeing something on the wall.
There is a photograph is affixed to the wall. In the photo is a man and a child. Both man and child resemble a younger GARDENER, however it is ambiguous. Still it is clear that they are father and child. Within the arms of a child is a small sapling, similar like the sapling ROBOT has destroyed.
ROBOT peers off to the side to the watch the GARDENER leaving the building. The robot sees the similarity between the people in the photo and the GARDENER. The GARDENER is seen reflected in the ROBOTs lens. The ROBOT nods, with new understanding, and runs off to catch up with the GARDENER.
Yes! You can make a cut to this scene and it flows and transitions well. We are indicated that they walk into the toolshed and there's continuity between the 2 scenes. The ending of this scene is an actual ending. The robot leaves the shed, and you can transition out or cut after this scene without breaking the flow of the action.
The Camera lingers on the photograph on the wall in the tool shed.
The photograph dissolves into a series of photographic images depicting the GARDENER and ROBOT doing many different tasks. The images depict the growing bond the pair forms as they work together in the garden. In one of these images ROBOT is seen emulating the GARDENER, wiping imaginary sweat from its brow. The pair is seen watering saplings, pruning leaves, and tending the central tree. The final image is that of the central tree, it is now full and healthy looking, and many acorns hang from the branches.
CROSS-DISSOLVE
Continuity and a transitional mechanic! Good!
A gentle breeze blows through the branches of the main tree, which is framed identically to the image from the previous sequence. The garden has changed. It is lush and well manicured. Brightly colored insects fly through the green. Most noticeable is the central tree, which is now robust and verdant, starkly contrasting the barren trunk seen previously.
Sitting on a bench, the GARDENER surveys the garden. He watches ROBOT tending to the tree. ROBOT, now working with care and consideration, prunes the tree. The GARDENER spots something on the ground, bends over, and picks up an acorn. It is healthy and has a gleam on its surface. Nodding in approval, the GARDENER sighs, and motions for ROBOT to come to him.
ROBOT walks to the GARDENER, and stands before him. The GARDENER reaches behind ROBOT. ROBOTs eye lens fades to black.
FADE TO BLACK
An establishing shot! And the way it is describes gives context and emotion of the scene!
The first few scenes are vague and need to be tightened up. A cut is used to indicate a break between actions, meaning that if it's use it as a transition, it "breaks" the flow and rhythm and pace of the scene.
Pacing is REALLY important not just between scenes but overall. The story should have a "flow" in which a scene moves between. . A story is immersive off of its execution. If the pacing is off the entire story will be choppy and have weird disconnects.
Shots are also really important. You can't have every shot be a flat angle of MS/FBS. Perfect example of the excruciating boringness is that train scene from the matrix. Yes composition matters and we get composition from our shots.
Our story is NOT THAT BORING. Like the pruning of the sapping there is nuances and subtitles that can make this sophisticated. If every aspect of this story isn't tightened, then it'll end up being dead, lifeless and completely mutilated.
Sorry for the really long rant guys. This has been bugging me for a while
Lots to address here, but I'm frankly too tired to do that right now. I'll look through this with fresh eyes in the morning.
ReplyDeleteOk, for starters, I was under the assumption that specific camera directions were to be avoided in screenplays, so I left as much direction out of it as possible. I was trying to get to the core of the story, and focus on basic descriptions of environment. I am not a writer first, so my text tends to be either flowery or very stark. I apologize if that causes confusion.
ReplyDelete"Okay... How is this shot composed? Do we start the short literally with the gardener standing in the middle of the garden?"
I removed the notion of camera angles from my mind when I was writing this, figuring we could get that resolved in storyboard. I realize now that perhaps I should have introduced things with a more pictorial composition in mind. Obviously I had composed the shots in my head, but I guess I did not explain the scenes to be easily understood by all. Mea culpa.
""Watches it with expectation" mean? This is very oblique!"
The term "watching with expectation" can be read as oblique. Sure. The idea I pictured was that of the facial expressions of someone who has installed a neat new program onto their computer and is waiting to see exactly what it would do. I figured this could be conveyed via the gardener's facial expression.
"If we're in the exterior of the toolshed does that mean that he pushes him towards the direction of the garden. The way this is written it implies we're in the threshold of the toolshed but outside at the same time. This needs to be clear!"
I thought the toolshed part was pretty clear. The threshold of the toolshed is a fairly large space, if I read the layout of the model and designs correctly. It is an open space with lots of ambient light, neither out or in. I'm not sure how to make that any clearer.
"There is neither a transition nor a segway from this last scene? Was there a fade? Is this a cut? Do we jump right into the digging of the hole? Is there an establishing shot since this is a completely different scene?"
I think we discussed how we would accomplish this in the critique of the storyboards. There are parts of the screenplay which I believe were easier to describe in pictures, but then I tend to think in pictures before words, so that might be the confusion.
"Do I fade out? If I do fade out of this there's a strange disconnect, because I'm doing this after an action."
ReplyDeleteWe can discuss the ways to end this scene I was trying to keep the camera out of this as I wrote it. I wanted to get the scenes organized first and then discuss transition.
"Same issues with the last scene. How did we get here? How do I transition into this?"
Same issues, same answer. We can do a cut from the exterior to the interior. I think that's an easy transition. We can worry about the transition after the scenes are done.
There's a lot here that you talk about that is unclear as to whether it is comment, argument, or question. I'll leave that and focus on your last statement;
Our story is NOT THAT BORING. Like the pruning of the sapping there is nuances and subtitles that can make this sophisticated. If every aspect of this story isn't tightened, then it'll end up being dead, lifeless and completely mutilated.
I think your concerns about making the scenes compositional strong with good angles is valid. I think we all want a good looking picture. I guess my implied sarcasm regarding the boringness of the story was missed. I think everyone in the class wants a good looking picture that will keep the audience captivated. Due to the pantomime nature of our story, I think the key to this more than the screenplay will be in the storyboard. Thus our task to refine and make the storyboards more readable and focused becomes clear.
It's a common goal.
If you have more to discuss about the screenplay please don't hesitate, and I will try to answer to the best of my ability. I apologize for the lack of literalism, and will make improvements in the screenplay where necessary.